Fair Value Estimate Changes: Facebook, Twitter, Caterpillar and More…

  By Kris Rosemann and Brian Nelson, CFA Let’s begin this edition of Recent Material Fair Value Estimate Changes’ with a discussion of some of the highest-profile names that made the list. If you require background reading on why we make changes to our valuation models, please see: What causes fair value estimates to change? Best Ideas Newsletter portfolio holding Facebook (FB) continues to separate itself from other social media companies, and we continue to be impressed by its free cash flow generating prowess and net cash-rich balance sheet. Our most recent fair value estimate increase comes largely as a result of greater optimism regarding the sustainability of the company’s pace of revenue growth, reflected by a hike in our mid-cycle … Read more

Solar Not So Bright

We continue to believe the solar industry is “uninvestable.” You don’t have to look much further than the write-up in any solar industry constituent’s 16-page report to get our straightforward opinion: The solar industry is extremely competitive and continually evolving as constituents strive to differentiate themselves to better compete within the broader electric power industry. Significant price reductions (per watt), reduced margins, and drastic market share shifts have become commonplace for participants. Profitability can be negatively impacted from government subsidies and sovereign capital that allow firms to operate unprofitably for extended periods of time. Production overcapacity is another major concern and will likely persist for some time. We think the structure of the solar industry is very poor. After the … Read more

The 20 Something’s Stock Portfolio

A version of this article appeared on our website March 31, 2015. <Our best ideas at any time are included in the Best Ideas Newsletter portfolio and Dividend Growth Newsletter portfolio.> The “20 Something’s Stock Portfolio” is the first in a series of articles where we get to the core of what many brand new investors want to do when they are first introduced to the stock market: find exciting companies that they are familiar with that will help compound their wealth over time. Other portfolios that we will share in this series include “The Ultra High Income Portfolio,” “The Economic Castle Portfolio,” “The Dividend Cushion Portfolio,” and “The Intelligent ETF Investor’s Portfolio,” among others. The series of portfolios will … Read more

New England Wins!

Does that mean we’re doomed in 2015? Don’t be silly. The Super Bowl indicator, which says that if a team from the NFC wins we’re in for a good year, is akin to reading the stars. But the AFC’s Patriots won the big game – so does that mean 2015 will disappoint? Perhaps 2015 will…but certainly not because of the Patriots won the Super Bowl. A person doesn’t have to look much further than the NFC’s New York Giants winning the Super Bowl in 2008 to understand why such things just don’t matter. The dawn of the Financial Crisis that year sent stocks a-tumbling. It’s unfortunate that such things get so much attention because it makes it sound like the … Read more

4 Friday Earnings Reports for Your Radar

Let’s dig into a number of reports from firms in the news Friday.   Abercrombie & Fitch (ANF)   Investors in teen retail stocks are literally trying to catch lightning with respect to fashion trends. Predicting fashion in any demographic isn’t easy, but we’d point to anticipating teen behavior as the most difficult analytical proposition within any retail segment. It shouldn’t be surprising that fundamentals within the teen retail space are volatile, and Abercrombie & Fitch’s third-quarter update matched such a profile. During the period, net sales in its third quarter fell 12% and comparable store sales dropped 10%.   From the release: Sales during the quarter were below expectations with comparable sales in September and October being significantly weaker … Read more

Valuentum’s Performance on Seeking Alpha

Image Source: TipRanks, as of November 2016 By Valuentum Editorial Staff Seeking Alpha recently published the returns of certain ‘buy’ and ‘sell’ calls for each author. We applaud the firm’s ongoing dedication to transparency of its authors, if not by name, by track record. Valuentum Securities is an independent research firm headed by President Brian Nelson, CFA. Out of the 2,000+ articles Valuentum has published on Seeking Alpha, the Seeking Alpha study covered 567 of them, spanning from May 16, 2011, through June 25, 2014. Long ideas: 508; short ideas: 59. The articles in the study spanned all sectors and market capitalizations. The study pulled articles that were either tagged by Valuentum as ‘long’ ideas or ‘short’ ideas within the … Read more

Valuentum Economic Castleâ„¢ Rating Update

Read: Keeping the Horse Before the Cart: Valuentum’s Economic Castle™ Rating The Economic Castle Focuses on the Magnitude of Economic Value Creation The Valuentum Economic Castle™ rating is an enhancement of the competitive advantage framework (commonly known as economic moat analysis) that has become widespread and ubiquitous within the investing world. Whereas an economic moat framework evaluates a firm on the basis of the sustainability and durability of its competitive advantages, Valuentum’s Economic Castle™ rating evaluates a firm on the basis of the firm’s future economic profit spread (return on invested capital less its weighted average cost of capital). The companies with the strongest Valuentum Economic Castle™ ratings are poised to generate the most economic value for shareholders in the … Read more

First Solar Disappoints

The solar industry is extremely competitive and continually evolving as constituents strive to differentiate themselves to better compete within the broader electric power industry. Significant price reductions (per watt), reduced margins, and drastic market share shifts have become commonplace for participants. Profitability can be negatively impacted from government subsidies and sovereign capital that allow firms to operate unprofitably for extended periods of time. Production overcapacity is another major concern and will likely persist for some time. We think the structure of the solar industry is very poor, and First Solar reminded us of this when it reported fourth-quarter results Tuesday. The leading global provider of photovoltaic (PV) solar energy solutions reported revenue in the fourth quarter that declined nearly $500 … Read more

Why We Didn’t Get Excited About First Solar

Tuesday afternoon, solar panel maker First Solar (click ticker for report: ) announced disappointing second-quarter results, confirming some of the issues we have long held with its business. Valuentum subscribers know that we don’t like the firm’s long-term prospects considering the industry’s ultra-competitiveness and First Solar’s forecast of weak gross margins. During the quarter, revenue at First Solar declined 46% year-over-year, to $520 million, more than $200 million short of consensus estimates. Earnings per share were 71% lower than a year ago, coming in at $0.37, again well below consensus expectations. Free cash flow was also materially weaker, registering $168 million (down 49% year-over-year) and equal to 32% of revenue. Image Source: FSLR 2Q 2013 Earnings Slides The situation for … Read more

First Solar Is Wise to Raise Capital

First Solar’s Wild Ride Without question, solar modules and systems maker First Solar (click ticker for report: ) has been among the most controversial stocks in our coverage list during the past few years. The stock recently popped back above the $50 level on positive earnings guidance for 2014 and 2015, after nearly falling into the single digits last summer.  Though we’ve recently increased our fair value estimate for the solar maker to $47 per share (at the time of this writing) as we’ve warmed up to its mid-decade outlook (which looked better than what we had previously anticipated), management made a wise (and opportunistic) decision to raise equity capital at current levels via the announcement of a secondary offering yesterday. … Read more