Fair Value Estimates Matter – Case Study: Boeing

Image Source: Boeing’s share price converged to our estimate of intrinsic value in the summer of 2019. The plane maker continues to navigate tumultuous skies with its 737 MAX. By Brian Nelson, CFA Dow Jones Industrial Average component Boeing (BA) continues to dominate news headlines, and not for good reason. Let’s revisit our March 2019 article for some background: The news for Boeing hasn’t been this bad since the doldrums of the 787 Dreamliner build some years ago now. The 737 narrowbody, the line-up all over the news of late, is the workhorse of the industry, and Boeing’s next generation 737 MAX has been the fastest-selling plane in the aerospace giant’s history. Most countries around the globe, including the US, … Read more

FB/FIZZ Methodologically Speaking and CMG, AAPL, BA!

By Brian Nelson, CFA Hi everyone, Hope you are doing great. There a few things I wanted to put on your radar this evening. We’re going to talk the importance of having CFA charterholder research at your advisory practice. We’ll discuss Facebook (FB) and National Beverage (FIZZ) in the context of our methodology, and we’re going to touch on a couple things at Chipotle (CMG), Apple (AAPL) and Boeing (BA). Did you hear about the 737 MAX 8? Not good. I also wanted to remind you of the new 40/40 Goal (click here), of which we are already making progress (the book reviews keep coming in). Thank you! First, just a quick reminder on the 40/40 Goal. We now have 15 reviews … Read more

The Bull Case for Airline Stocks?

Image Source: BriYYZ Warren Buffett has famously said that airline stocks are horrible long-term investments, but his vast portfolio now owns a number of airlines. What’s the bull case for owning these capital-intensive, cyclical and often boom-and-bust stocks? By Brian Nelson, CFA Last year, the Oracle of Omaha Warren Buffett shocked the investment world when his company Berkshire Hathaway (BRK.A, BRK.B) disclosed that it held stakes in American Airlines (AAL), United Continental (UAL), Delta (DAL) and Southwest (LUV). For a die-hard, economic-moat investor, thinking about taking a stake in an airline seems crazy. After all, Buffett himself used to joke that he had an 1-800 number that he could call anytime he had the urge to buy an airline stock … Read more

United’s Passenger Debacle An Immaterial Investment Consideration

Image Source: Business Insider  The major airlines in the US have done a fantastic job capitalizing on the ongoing upswing in air travel demand, but their economically-sensitive business models remain the most operationally-leveraged out of any industry group in our coverage. This should be investors’ biggest concern: A downturn in the global economy and competitive pricing pressures are far greater worries for investors than United’s recent passenger debacle. However, as with many news-oriented items (as opposed to materially-relevant, investment-related items), United’s misstep is making headlines in a big way. Though the footage in this article is appalling, investors in airline stocks have much more important things to worry about, in our view. By Brian Nelson, CFA The airline industry has … Read more

Warren Buffett Is Back Into Airlines, Should You?

Warren Buffett has changed his mind about airline stocks… In this 10-minute podcast, the Valuentum analyst team talks all about the hazards of the airline business model from substantial operating leverage to the risks of volatile jet fuel costs to bankruptcies and beyond. The team also highlights the long-term passenger growth prospects of the sector, and recent consolidation that has brewed a more optimistic tone from industry observers. To view Valuentum’s updated YouTube page, please see here. Ticckerized for airline-related equities around the globe. Brian Nelson, CFA: The worst sort of business is one that grows rapidly requires significant capital to engender the growth and then earns little or no money. Think airlines. There’s a durable competitive advantage that has proven … Read more

Brexit: Secession Bells Are Ringing!

First Baptist Church in Columbia, S.C., where the first secession convention in the United States opened on Dec. 17, 1860. Source: Library of Congress, Washington, DC. Photo. Encyclopædia Britannica Online. Web. 24 Jun. 2016. Global markets are plunging, and the implosion may still be in the early innings. Market valuations remain stretched among stagnant global economic growth, and “Brexit” may be the catalyst for a correction. In the paraphrased words of the well-known The Day of the Jackal author, Frederick Forsyth: the peasants have spoken. On June 23, the UK (EWU) held a referendum, in which anyone of voting age could take part, to decide whether the country should leave the European Union. The turnout was incredible at nearly 72%, and … Read more

AMR Likely to Split Massive Order Between Boeing, Airbus

This article appeared on Seeking Alpha. Please view disclosures: https://seekingalpha.com/article/280307-amr-likely-to-split-massive-order-between-boeing-airbus As we outlined a few weeks ago in “AMR’s Big Order to Pressure Cash Flow, Boeing in Precarious Position,” we indicated the increasing likelihood that AMR (which holds American Airlines) may split a massive $15 billion-plus order between Boeing (BA) and Airbus to replace its aging fleet of narrowbodies. This would represent a huge shift at the major carrier, as AMR currently flies all-Boeing aircraft. Verbatim from our July 1 report: Boeing is in a rather precarious position. Airbus has claimed all along that it will capture customers currently flying the 737 with its A320neo (new engine option), an upgrade to its A320 that has the option to sport more fuel-efficient engines. The … Read more

AMR’s Big Order to Pressure Cash Flow, Boeing in Precarious Position

This article originally appeared on Seeking Alpha. Please view disclosures: https://seekingalpha.com/article/277628-amrs-big-order-to-pressure-cash-flow-boeing-in-precarious-position Shortly after we released our analysis of the fleets of the largest domestic carriers, The Wall Street Journal reported that AMR Corp. (AMR) is interested in ordering as many as 250 planes from either Boeing (BA) or Airbus (EADSY.PK). Our analysis, the summary graph of which we provide below, indicated that AMR is roughly on par with Delta (DAL) for having the oldest fleet (read fuel-inefficient) among the Big 4 domestic majors, so we view this move as inevitable. (Click chart to expand) The Wall Street Journal also indicated that the order value could be as high as $15 billion (comprising about 250 planes), and we suspect the new aircraft being evaluated will … Read more

Airbus Has Boeing’s Back Against the Wall, Seek Opportunities in Supply Chain

This article originally appeared on Seeking Alpha. Please view disclosures: https://seekingalpha.com/article/276439-airbus-has-boeings-back-against-the-wall-seek-opportunities-in-supply-chain Last week in anticipation of the Paris Air Show–a huge event for the aviation industry–we outlined our forecasts for market share in the narrowbody aircraft segment, which showed Airbus’ A320 gaining a clear lead during the next few decades.  So far during the show, Airbus has received a plethora of orders for its A320neo (new engine option), a re-engining of its popular A320, which competes with Boeing’s 737NG [and within a few years, entrants from around the globe: Comac’s C919 from China, Bombardier’s (BDRBF.PK) CSeries, and the Irkut/UAC MS-21 from Russia]. Orders for the A320neo are coming from around the globe, with Airbus garnering wins from India’s Indigo, Chile’s LAN Airlines (LFL), and domestic carrier Republic (RJET). We’re currently watching for any major shifts within the discount airline … Read more