WPZ

Market’s Swooning: Bye Bye Energy MLPs, Part II

by

Things were ugly again during the trading session February 8, but you were expecting the weakness. There’s nothing surprising, and we continue to wait to scoop up undervalued gems once the tide of this market turns. Topping the news today was the abrupt replacement of the CFO of Energy Transfer Equity (ETE)/Energy Transfer Partners (ETP) coupled with the sell-off in Chesapeake Energy (CHK) on news of a probable bankruptcy, which set the tone among midstream MLPs (AMLP), the index diving aggressively. Followers of Valuentum were far ahead of these developments, “Focus on ETE, Not ETP, Strive for Balance and Stick to the SEC Filings,””Alert: Energy Transfer Equity Is More than 7x Leveraged!,” “Energy MLPs Continue Swoon,” and our body of … Read more

Valuentum: Time to Load Up on Kinder Morgan?

by

On January 20, Kinder Morgan (KMI) reported fourth-quarter results, and absent 1) a large goodwill impairment charge related to its core midstream natural gas assets, 2) a reduction to its estimate for backlog of future potential business, and 3) warning that further goodwill impairments are around the corner if energy resource pricing remains depressed, quarterly performance wasn’t all that bad (or at least not as bad as some had been expecting). Kinder Morgan had previously announced a 75% dividend cut and a very costly preferred equity issuance just a few weeks ago as it continues to work to get its financial house in order. Our $20 per share fair value estimate is unchanged at this time. We’re starting to like what we’re … Read more

Valuentum: Energy MLPs Continue Swoon

by

Energy master limited partnerships (AMLP, AMZ) continue to be in a world of hurt as investors reevaluate the sustainability of distribution streams and reassess the fundamentals on a pure traditional free cash flow basis. Many, however, continue to point to uncertainty related to the completion of the deal between Energy Transfer Equity (ETE) and Williams Partners (WMB) as reason for the sharp drops, but if you recall, both stocks collapsed on the announcement of the deal in October, both stocks collapsed when speculation grew a deal would not be completed earlier this month, and both stocks collapsed when the deal was reiterated last week. Instead, we think the market is focused on tangible long-term fundamentals, free cash flow generation, leverage … Read more

Excited About Putting Cash to Work…Eventually

by

Investors are fretting over a lot of things as of late. China (FXI) announced January 19 that fourth-quarter GDP fell to 6.8%, with many noting that the measure was a 25-year low. Even if you believe that number, which may be a stretch in light of collapsing local stock markets in Shanghai and Shenzhen, the outlook can’t be much better. Steel mills across the country are reeling, and while published housing numbers don’t look that bad, we have a difficult time believing the Chinese banks are in good shape. HSBC (HSBC), Standard Chartered, and Citigroup (C) remain most exposed to what we would describe to be the growing likelihood of a contagion from weakening commodity-dependent sectors in the country. Intel … Read more

Bye Bye Energy MLPs

by

West Texas crude oil prices (USO) just broke through $32 per barrel to the downside for the first time since 2003. Share prices of those in the energy complex (XLE) continue to reel, and we maintain our view that the tremendous fallout in energy master limited partnerships (AMLP, AMZ) may not be over. From our perspective, the MLP business model may not survive in its present state, as equity markets continue to “wise up” to the artificial equity pricing paradigm that has centered on the group’s financially-engineered payouts. Without an artificial pricing paradigm to “prop up” their equity prices, for example, the incentive to perpetuate such a business model is substantially reduced. Distribution cuts would then inevitably ensue as a … Read more

FAQ: Help Me Understand Your Research on MLPs

by

FAQ: It looks like your fair value estimates and your adjusted Dividend Cushion ratios aren’t bad. What gives? A: Thank you for your question. The Valuentum process rests on uncovering undervalued companies that are trading at a discount to intrinsic value, but also ones that are supported by the market via strong technical and momentum indicators. The latter consideration is absent from most, if not all of the energy sector, including MLPs. MLPs themselves, however, have a nuanced valuation adjustment in our process that leads us to have significantly less conviction than in other areas. Pasted below is a slide deck that mentions that adjustment (i.e. we exclude growth capex, even though we feel that it is an integral part of … Read more

Master Limited Partnership Model Still At Risk

by

Valuentum’s President Brian Nelson’s concerns regarding the master limited partnership business model became mainstream in June of this year. In his piece, “5 Reasons Why We Think Kinder Morgan’s Shares Will Collapse,” an article that itself may go down in history as one of the most timely pieces of research ever written–in light of Kinder Morgan’s (KMI) eventual collapse–Mr. Nelson said of the MLP space at that time: Most, if not all, MLPs report distributable cash flow (DCF), which does not in the calculation consider growth capex, an important driver behind the generation of increased cash flow from operations in the future. When MLPs report distribution coverage ratios, this particular calculation also backs out growth capex from the equation, instead … Read more

Williams’ Rejection, Medtronic’s Hike, eBay’s Sale, and Hershey’s Disappointment

by

Williams Companies Rejects Offer from Energy Transfer Equity Natural gas pipeline company Williams Companies (WMB) has seen shares jump after Energy Transfer Equity (ETE) confirmed reports that it had made a bid to acquire the company. Despite the all-equity offer of $64 per share representing a 32% premium to Williams’ June 19 closing price, the offer was rejected by the firm as significantly too low. ETE has made multiple attempts to talk with Williams’ management about a possible merger in the past half year, and ETE has said its offer is contingent on the abortion of Williams’ pending purchase of Williams Partners (WPZ). The initial offer came on May 19, six days after Williams Companies announced it would buy Williams … Read more