Lack of Winter Weather Hits Dick’s Sporting Goods and Big 5; We’re Not Fans of Either
Dick’s Sporting Goods (DKS) and Big 5 (BGFV) recently pre-announced dismal guidance for the fourth quarter of 2011. Though both companies cited a lack of winter weather as the main driver of poor same store sales growth, we think the stories at each company are quite different. Dick’s remains a steadily growing, well-run business focused on driving high returns on invested capital, whereas Big 5 is an inferior player focused on smaller markets that’s struggled to find its way. However, as with any investment, getting the right price remains key to our decision-making process, even for firms that may not be best-in-breed. Risk/reward at Dick’s Sporting Goods isn’t very compelling right now. With our fair value of Dick’s at $31 per share, and … Read more